.
Feedback

Decades Old Malibu Beach Esplanade Project Re-emerges

Little is known about the project, which was first proposed in the 1980s and includes plans for walkways, bikeways and a viewing deck over a 3.5 mile stretch from the Malibu Pier to the Malibu Lagoon.

The Malibu Parks and Recreation Commission is exploring the Malibu Esplanade Project, a resurrected plan from the 1980s to build a bike path and viewing platforms from the Malibu Pier to the Malibu Lagoon.

In a unanimous vote Tuesday, the commission voted to form a subcommittee made up of Commissioners Carl Randall, Graeme Clifford and Steve Parks to gather facts about the project and present them at the next meeting.

Bob Stallings, Malibu's Parks and Recreation director, said the project was assigned to the commission by City Manager Jim Thorsen.

Stallings identified the person behind the project as Ann Ryan, an architect with a studio in Malibu. Ryan originally proposed the project in the 1980s when her nonprofit received grants from the California Coastal Conservancy, California Department of Parks and Los Angeles County.

More recently, Ryan made several attempts to solicit grant funds from the city in 2010 and 2011, but none of the requests were funded, according to Stallings.

“She communicated to [Thorsen] and he communicated to me that he would like this commission to get more detailed information,” Stallings said.  

The subcommittee and others in the city will meet with the designers and project representatives to find out more about the project.

According to an excerpt from the California Coastal Conservancy grant application, the project area would extend from the Malibu Pier to the entrance of the Malibu Lagoon State Park.

"This entire area forms the center of the Malibu community and serves as a recreational attraction of statewide significance," the application states.

The plans call for 3.5 miles of pedestrian walkways, bikeways, a viewing deck at Surfrider Beach and access to trails in the Santa Monica Mountains and the shops in the Cross Creek area. To accommodate the walkways and bikeways, the project calls for the widening of the Malibu Bridge over the Malibu Lagoon on Pacific Coast Highway, a major undertaking.

Two plans, which are dated from 1992, were displayed in the room at Malibu City Hall during the commission's meeting. One page advertised a “viewing deck and ramp at Surfriders Beach, Malibu.” The other showed a map of a wide, sandy Surfrider Beach, including Pacific Coast Highway, the Adamson House and the Cross Creek area.

The names on the designs are Ann Ryan Design and Dennis Turner, landscape architect.

Stallings said that after finding out the facts about the project, the commission will review the plans and recommend to the City Council whether the project is feasible and if the city should provide any grant money.

“There is a lot of exploratory type work before anything happens with this project,” Stallings said.

Four community members attended the meeting to seek answers about the project.

“I’m opposed to this project as it stands,” Malibu resident Mari Stanley said. Stanley also asked that the Public Works and other city departments review the plans as well.

Wendi Werner said she believes this is the same project that her husband, Steve Dunn, and other surfers fought 20 years ago.

“He says this is not Orange County. This is not Venice Beach,” Werner said.

Both Werner and Stanley said they believe many in Malibu will oppose the project.

Commissioner Ren Smith said he feels the project's 1980s version seems complex and unfeasible.

"I was shocked that someone introduced this after the issue with the lagoon. It doesn’t seem feasible to me. There’s a whole group of people that need to look into it," Smith said.

Malibu Surfrider Beach was dedicated as the first World Surfing Reserve in 2010. In 2009, California State Parks won the Los Angeles Conservancy Preservation Award for its restoration of the Malibu Pier.

Terry December 19, 2012 at 11:35 am
. I have been a malibu resident and surfer for over 50 years and i support a beautification project for surfrider beach. the landscaping, sidewalk area and bathrooms are discussting for world famous surfrider beach. the bathrooms should be more tastfully done. shower drainage needs to be disposed of differently without errosion on the beach. the lifeguard storage garage should not be located where it is and it should be moved to where the other vehicles are stored. there were no hearings or permits for this garage which replaced a storage container. the county planted the poorly chosen non natural trees which also need to be removed. the stairway to the beach was built by some very untallented designers.
Jeff December 19, 2012 at 02:42 pm
You've got to be kidding me. The Malibu 'government' seems intent on ruining everything about Malibu. Pathetic is the nicest phrase I can come up with the way these self-indulgent, overpaid losers. I've watched them for over 20 years in their attempts to turn Malibu into just another cash & trash California beach town.
J. Goldberg
Daniel D Hillman MD December 19, 2012 at 03:06 pm
The Esplanade Project definitely enhances Surfrider Beach for all---the public, the disabled (who will now have beach access ramps and bathrooms for the first time in Malibu history), the city of Malibu image, surfers, and residents; a beautiful job of design by Ann Ryan (a longtime neighbor-Malibu resident; the City Council is unanimously supportive--my congratulations to all who made this vision from the 80's happen.
Jessica E. Davis (Editor) December 19, 2012 at 04:35 pm
Nothing has been approved. The Malibu Parks and Recreation Commission only formed a subcommittee to find out more about the project. It does not have the power to approve anything, only to make a recommendation to the City Council.
M Stanley December 19, 2012 at 04:50 pm
The nonprofit Malibu Beach Esplanade is not active according to online sources, it has a Suspended status and has no income (as of Aug 2012 reports from CA State sources). Hard to imagine any final approvals could have even been encouraged by the City of Malibu for a defunct group outside the governmental regulations established for receipt of governmental funds and donations by public members.
Don't know what you're referring to Dr. Hillman, name the city council members that you seem to be referring to as a group approval and please direct us to the documents that back up your statements. Seems that you're implying a few issues that might be Brown Act violations if true, illuminate us all please with your insider knowledge and close contact to the project originator.
R Y A N December 19, 2012 at 06:13 pm
I am NOT Ann Ryan, FYI. Concerns over this ongoing Beach Esplenade have back-burnered it for decades, but it has some merit. The historic Adamson House's brick wall was a controversial issue on widening the Malibu Lagoon Bridge in the early 1990's before it fell in from natural storms (the PCH vehicle bridge -- not the bridges in the lagoon recklessly eliminated by State Parks reckless destruction of Malibu Lagoon itself). Governor Wilson rapidly rebuilt the PCH "Malibu Lagoon" Bridge to previous width under an emergency permit -- sidsestepping Fish Games, Skate Perks, Beach Expletives, or Historical stagnificance.
Daniel D Hillman MD December 19, 2012 at 09:07 pm
OOOPPPSS! Thank you M Stanley (apologies for not knowing your first name but it is apparently not published) --for correcting me; I was so enthusiastic about the Esplanade project that i hastily took unanimous vote of Rec and Parks statement to be a City Council vote --mia culpa.
June Carson December 21, 2012 at 02:46 am
What a great plan. Let's finally do something for the people of Malibu. We need paths that link our city. Sounds like we might have a real city rather than a bunch of roads and stores. GREAT IDEA - LETS DO IT!! June Carson
BOOGER December 23, 2012 at 05:10 pm
why waste the money? stupid idea... you guys have already ruined the lagoon. cant we just quit while were ahead? first point has been that way for so long. cant we just leave something alone? malibu has never been the type of place for face lifts, but now, all of a sudden, everything needs a face lift. cant we just keep malibu, malibu?
Carla Rowland February 21, 2013 at 12:09 am
FYI... At Surfrider Beach, First Point more specifically, there is and has been handicap access to the beach, as well as to the bathrooms, for MANY years now. This is just another plan to "beautify" Malibu with more concrete and destruction of what we surfers, lovers and locals who frequent this beach DAILY, love and don't want changed. Those truly unfamiliar with the inner workings of this historically significant and designated "world surfing reserve" should not speak on behalf of those of us who are acutely aware of what is really going on! KEEP MALIBU COUNTRY!!!

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Malibu Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Max June 18, 2013 at 09:02 am
Firemen are my true heroes. Not once, but twice, have they saved my house over the years, as wellRead More as where I worked most of my career. We cannot thank them enough for their yeomen efforts and hard work. When they are on the lines, we always provide them with food and drink, which is the least that we can do. We also welcome them when they make their annual inspections of properties here to ensure that homeowners clear their brush. When I was in school, we were visited by Firemen, who handed out badges and booklets on fire safety. I was proud to wear my "Junior Fireman" badge back then, and feel the same today!
Don Schmitz June 19, 2013 at 02:51 pm
We truly are blessed with the best first responders a community could hope for. A nod also to theRead More excellent building and planning standards we have implimented over the last few decades. Homes are now required to have dual pane glass, stucco (or commensurate) siding, class A roofs, adequate access, significant water storage, and the essential 200 ft. brush clearance. The proof has been demonstrated, and the results are impressive.
Rainbow in Malibu 20112
Yvonne Carrison June 17, 2013 at 09:24 am
Luv the rainbow over our heavenly canyon, we are truly blessed to live here! Gratitude
Snookie Ravioli June 17, 2013 at 08:32 am
I doubt it matters much. The Malibu mayor is no more than the presiding officer of the councilRead More meetings. In a council-manager form of government, which Malibu has, the mayor has very little power--a good thing in Malibu considering its history. The mayor in Malibu is a ceremonial position and s/he has no more actual power than the other council members. The game of musical chairs is not a bad thing in the Malibu council. Consider the alternative!
Snookie Ravioli June 17, 2013 at 08:44 am
A follow-up to Tom Brady's idea of annelected mayor. That woukd require a change in the form ofRead More government in Malibu to a Mayor-Manager form. The Mayor-Manager form is best for larger cities. Most cities the size of Malibu have the Council-Manager form because experience shows it works best for small cities. Having an elected mayor with the power of an elected mayor could create more problems than it solves. It would completely change the political environent in Malibu, and not for the better. Having weak, rotating mayors serves Malibu well.
Dee Rivellino June 17, 2013 at 06:07 pm
How do I explain why we have such a turnover in Mayors.? Because in intelligent communities theRead More answer would sound very pathetic. ..Well, let me start from the beginning when no one on the first, second, third, fourth, etc. Councils could decide how long the Mayor should serve ..so some genius came up with rotation and actually that's ok because all the Mayor does anyway is pose for pictures with the current flock of so called Celebrities. This goes on the list of why Malibu is always so different from other normal town around us.(An article I wrote months ago in the Surfside news) The Council meets, accomplishes little, a new Mayor is selected and life goes on. ... Elected officials(that's a joke too since only less than 3,000 people ever show up to vote out of 13,000 residents).. You can't ask questions like why our Mayor moves like the waves of the Ocean when most of the people in Malibu have no clue whats going on behind those thick doors at City Hall....the ones NOT OPEN TO THE PUBLIC. Good for Burt, its only taken him 18 months to ask the hard questions.
Ted Vaill June 11, 2013 at 12:24 pm
Sounds like a great father, like his son. My father died in 1989, of cancer, but was a happy,Read More positive man to the end. My mother remarried nine years later, and remarked before she died at age 98 that she was blessed to be married to two wonderful men.
Max June 12, 2013 at 01:46 am
Dear Burt, A very toughing piece about your dear father. If only more fathers these days had theRead More values and character that your father had, this world would be a much better, more caring and loving place. I, too, had a father that was very giving and supportive of me. As both of my parents were holocaust survivors, my upbringing was greatly influenced by their horrific experiences in Poland, Czechoslovakia and Germany: losing 80% of our families, being in over a dozen different concentration camps and facing death and torture continuously. It’s amazing that they were able to lead “normal” lives upon immigrating to the US. Never finishing high school in Poland and not speaking a word of English, he attended night school (Fairfax High), worked during the days in the subcontractor business (he manufactured venetian blinds, screens and louver windows, all from scratch, decades before they were imported), became a citizen (as did my late Mom) and raised a family. They eked out a living (lower middle class), sent my younger brother and I to Hebrew school every day after public school classes, encouraged us to strive in school and somehow supported my hobby of being a radio amateur and my brother in violin studies. My parents always wanted me to become an electronics engineer (probably based on the dream my father had before WW2). Several of his proudest moments were when I got accepted into the physics grad schools of Princeton, Harvard, Caltech, Stanford and UCLA; when I received my PhD from Caltech; when I authored a cover feature article in Scientific American; and when I married my Beshert (soul mate). As a kid, I had a mild connection to you, Burt. I loved rulers, be they the fancy compact metallic ones that retracted by the push of a button, the ones that had a mechanical crank to reel in the ruler or the foldable wooden rulers (that I always associated with a magic trick), which I would use in school, the lab and measuring Ham radio antennas that I built as a kid. All this was influenced by my dear father, equipped with rulers of all kinds, which he used on a daily basis when precisely measuring windows and door frames, manufacturing venetian blinds, screen doors, etc. As a 5-year old, my father would take me to his 2-man shop and, as they worked, I would run around the place with various rulers and magnets in tow, measuring everything in sight and picking up nails and hardware. I guess the only difference between us is that you became a ruler and I became one who is ruled. Happy Father’s Day, Burt!
Sandra Peltola June 8, 2013 at 08:14 am
Time to support Vital Zuman Farm, 60 years of service to the community. If you have not been to theRead More farm, you must, before another season goes by! Get your nature on, see the crops growing, meet friends, eat good food, listen to music outdoors, view exceptional art; ALL AT VITAL ZUMAN FARM on Saturday June 22, 2013 from 12:00 noon till 6:00pm. More Info: 310-924-2210
Far Infrared Sauna w/LED Lights
Lisa Knickmeyer, L.Ac., DA June 7, 2013 at 01:05 pm
Endermologie is perfect for the summer! It increases fat cell metabolism, addresses trapped fat andRead More streamlines the body and treats fat resistant to diet and exercise.
Super Dume
Mizzy Pacheco June 7, 2013 at 05:37 pm
Thanks. Moon rise.
Ashley W. Lewis June 9, 2013 at 05:06 pm
Ashley Lewis Thanks for sharing the beautiful photo of the fabulous moon and rocks. Curious whatRead More kind of camera and lens was used?
Mizzy Pacheco June 9, 2013 at 08:29 pm
Thanks, that was taken with a canon 5d mark ii with the cannon f4 70-200mm set at about 125mm
Lois Livoti June 5, 2013 at 03:52 pm
Wow - how fantastic to see Jim Palmer's Malibu Vineyards on the map for world class wine making.Read More Also I want to congratulate you on your recent "Best of Class" award and 95 point rating from the Los Angeles International wine competition for your 2010 Malibu Vineyards Estate Syrah. Well done!!!!
kim devane June 6, 2013 at 10:15 am
Well done Jim! You are putting Malibu on the map for world class wine. Congratulations! kim &Read More larry
This sycamore tree on Trancas Canyon Road was six inches -- and five votes -- away from getting ground up to make way for four more unsafe, angle parking places on Trancas Canyon Rd. Now, can we get rid of the numbskull loading zone at PCH's corner?
J. Flo June 4, 2013 at 02:11 pm
I found the meeting, the speakers and the Planning Commission to be very impressive. Well-thoughtRead More out, intelligent.
Hans Laetz June 4, 2013 at 07:33 pm
So interesting to hear the applicant's lawyer explain that the billboard was appropriate becauseRead More "this is a commercial area." Oh, dear dear dear. That sort of explains the whole problem.
Proud Elitist June 10, 2013 at 06:54 am
First the Paige Sports Arena sign at Univ Missouri Columbia comes down. Next Trancas sign comesRead More down. Girl, you got some bad luck with signs.